Auto Insurance Complaints & Companies

Browse the worst rated companies in the Auto Insurance category. See 45 businesses with published consumer complaints.

45 companies tracked

Category size

45 companies

Complaint volume

1,612 total complaints

Showing 67 of 67 companies

Top complaint magnets

Companies with the highest number of published complaints in this category.

Progressive

475 complaints logged

Rated 1.5 out of 5

State Farm

348 complaints logged

Rated 3.0 out of 5

GEICO

305 complaints logged

Rated 1.0 out of 5

Allstate

177 complaints logged

Rated 1.0 out of 5

Esurance

65 complaints logged

Rated 1.0 out of 5

Nationwide Insurance

49 complaints logged

Rated 3.0 out of 5

All companies

Sorted by complaint volume

Progressive

475 complaints

1.5/5

State Farm

348 complaints

3.0/5

GEICO

305 complaints

1.0/5

Allstate

177 complaints

1.0/5

Esurance

65 complaints

1.0/5

Nationwide Insurance

49 complaints

3.0/5

Fred Loya

31 complaints

2.5/5

Farmers

25 complaints

Mercury Insurance

23 complaints

1.5/5

SafeAuto

20 complaints

1.0/5

American Family

18 complaints

1.0/5

21st Century Insurance

9 complaints

2.0/5

Grange Insurance

7 complaints

5.0/5

Shelter Insurance

5 complaints

5.0/5

UPC Insurance

5 complaints

5.0/5

North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance

4 complaints

5.0/5

Kentucky Farm Bureau

4 complaints

5.0/5

Erie Insurance

4 complaints

5.0/5

NJM Insurance

4 complaints

5.0/5

American National

3 complaints

5.0/5

State Auto

3 complaints

5.0/5

Kemper

3 complaints

5.0/5

Farmers Insurance

2 complaints

5.0/5

Heritage Insurance

2 complaints

5.0/5

Universal Insurance Holdings Inc.

1 complaints

5.0/5

The Cincinnati Insurance Cos.

1 complaints

5.0/5

Tennessee Farmers Insurance Companies

1 complaints

5.0/5

Alfa Mutual Group

1 complaints

5.0/5

Texas Farm Bureau Insurance

1 complaints

5.0/5

Tokio Marine

1 complaints

5.0/5

Farm Bureau Financial Services

1 complaints

5.0/5

Plymouth Rock of New Jersey

1 complaints

5.0/5

Markel

1 complaints

5.0/5

Westfield Insurance

1 complaints

5.0/5

Citizens Property Insurance Corp.

1 complaints

5.0/5

Michigan Farm Bureau

1 complaints

5.0/5

Safety Insurance

1 complaints

5.0/5

Travelers

1 complaints

Auto Club Exchange

1 complaints

5.0/5

CSAA Insurance Exchange

1 complaints

5.0/5

Auto Club Insurance Association

1 complaints

5.0/5

Amica

1 complaints

5.0/5

COUNTRY Financial

1 complaints

5.0/5

The Hanover Insurance Group

1 complaints

5.0/5

Southern Farm Bureau Casualty

1 complaints

5.0/5

Seminole Casualty Insurance

0 complaints

Hanover

0 complaints

Freeway Auto Insurance

0 complaints

NetQuote.com

0 complaints

Amica Auto Insurance

0 complaints

Cost-U-Less Insurance

0 complaints

Automobile Club of Southern California

0 complaints

Permanent General Auto Insurance (PGAC)

0 complaints

Alfa

0 complaints

American Access Casualty

0 complaints

Bristol West Insurance

0 complaints

Mendota

0 complaints

American Freedom Insurance

0 complaints

Dairyland Insurance

0 complaints

Fiesta Auto Insurance

0 complaints

Long Island Insurance Company

0 complaints

Unitrin Direct Auto Insurance

0 complaints

Wawanesa Auto Insurance

0 complaints

Arbella Insurance

0 complaints

Lincoln General Insurance

0 complaints

Chubb

0 complaints

FEDNAT

0 complaints

5.0/5